How a CAM Property Management Firm Turned Its Reviews Around

Case Study · Reputation Management

Property management is one of the hardest businesses to review well. Happy residents rarely post, and frustrated ones always do. MyNINA built a reputation campaign that started by listening, and in four months the reviews followed.

+49new Google reviews
+0.8star rating increase
58%more reviews in 4 months
4,000contacts reached

At a glance

The client and the campaign

Client
Advanced Property Management
Industry
CAM property management
Location
Rockledge, Florida
Contacts
About 4,000 residents, owners & boards
Timeline
June 25 – Oct 26, 2026 (ongoing)
MyNINA Assists used
Reputation Management, CRM & Follow-up, Review QR code

The challenge

A tough industry and a 2.6-star first impression

Nobody calls their property manager to say thanks. They call when the pool is closed, the gate is broken or the assessment goes up. For years, that meant the only people leaving reviews were the ones having a bad day.

When we started, the firm had 84 Google reviews and a 2.6-star rating. That was the first thing prospective associations and new residents saw, and it didn't reflect the work the team was doing every day. They had thousands of satisfied contacts. Nobody had ever asked them.

Starting point · June 2026
2.6
★★★★★

84 Google reviews, mostly from residents who only reached out when something went wrong.

The approach

We asked for feedback before we asked for reviews

  • 1

    Organized the contact list

    We brought about 4,000 residents, owners and board contacts into the CRM and segmented them by community.

  • 2

    Sent a short feedback survey

    A friendly text or email asked how the team was doing. Residents felt heard, and management got real insight into what was working.

  • 3

    Invited every respondent to review

    Each person got a survey link asking for feedback and reviews.

  • 4

    Routed concerns to the team

    Problems mentioned in the survey went directly to management so they could follow up and fix them.

  • 5

    Followed up automatically

    A friendly reminder went to anyone who hadn't responded yet.

  • 6

    Responded to every review

    The team was alerted to each new review and replied quickly, good or bad.

Listening first built goodwill, and goodwill turned into reviews.

The results

From 2.6 to 3.4 stars in four months

JUNE 25, 2026
2.6★★★★★
84 Google reviews
Property management company · Rockledge, FL
➜
OCTOBER 26, 2026
3.4★★★★★
133 Google reviews
Property management company · Rockledge, FL

The firm added 49 new Google reviews, a 58% increase, and raised its rating by nearly a full star. Moving an average that much takes a lot of good reviews: the new reviews have averaged well above 4.5 stars. And the campaign is still running.

Advanced Property Management Google rating rising from 2.6 stars with 84 reviews to 3.4 stars with 133 reviews
Scan to review

Reviews that keep coming

A custom QR code for in-office reviews

The firm now has its own review QR code. When a resident has a good visit, they scan and review in seconds, no searching required.

Front deskInvoicesNewslettersCommunity noticesBusiness cards

Every interaction is now a chance to earn a review.

Why it worked

Most happy customers just need to be asked

They already had the customers

We didn't buy leads. We reached people who already knew the firm.

Feedback built trust

Asking “how are we doing?” first made the review request feel personal, not pushy.

It runs on autopilot

Requests, reminders and alerts happen automatically, so the team can focus on their communities.

It doesn't stop

The QR code and ongoing requests keep fresh reviews coming in.

Your turn

Is your reputation telling the whole story?

If your best customers aren't the ones leaving reviews, we can change that. Book a free conversation and we'll show you how many reviews are sitting in your contact list right now.

Book my free call Get Reputation Management Or call 386-282-5290

MyNINA

Dominate your market with MyNINA.

Daytona regional chamber of commerce

Proud Member

Daytona Regional Chamber of Commerce

Port Orange South daytona chamber of commerce

Proud Member

Port Orange South Daytona Chamber of Commerce

Victory Lane BNI

Proud Member

BNI Victory Lane

Contact

386-282-5290

Reach Us

Copyright © 2026. My NINA. All rights reserved.